We need your long-term help now: please become an FSFE supporter today, so that we can continue to stand up for your and the next generations’ freedom.

Ta strona nie została jeszcze przetłumaczona. Na tej stronie dowiesz się, jak można pomóc w tłumaczeniu lub w inny sposób.


Open letter to Commissioner Kroes


Dear Commissioner Kroes,

regarding the antitrust investigations led by DG COMP against Microsoft, you have let it be known that you would like to close a number of open cases very soon. This includes an ongoing investigation into Microsoft's practice of tying its Internet Explorer Browser to its Windows operating systems, and a pending complaint about Microsoft's consistent failure to share interoperability information for its desktop programs with competitors.

At the Free Software Foundation Europe (FSFE), we have long followed your Directorate's excellent work in ensuring competition in Europe. We participated as an interested third party in the Commission's case against Microsoft about interoperability in the workgroup server market. Today, FSFE is an interested third party in the Commission's proceedings against Microsoft based on Opera's complaint about the company's practice of tying Internet Explorer to its Windows operating system. We also follow closely any progress regarding the complaint filed by ECIS on Microsoft's refusal to share interoperability information for a number of its desktop applications.

It is our view that DG Competition has done splendid work in all these cases. We are writing to you today to express our concerns about the consequences that an insufficiently strong settlement in those cases would have on the European software market. In our view, the terms for a settlement which Microsoft offered in July of this year are not an effective remedy against the company's dominant position in the European market for desktop software.

We have published an analysis of the most important points for effective antitrust measures. I would like to draw your attention to this publication:

As stated there, our core concerns in the browser case are the following:

While the Commission has not yet issued a statement of objections regarding Microsoft's failure to share interoperability information with competitors, a settlement is being sought on this issue as well. Again, FSFE has analysed Microsoft's proposed interoperability undertaking, and has found it insufficient to establish competition in the European market for desktop software.

It is worth noting that in many cases, the strongest competitors with Microsoft's desktop applications are Free Software. OpenOffice is a case in point, constituting as it does the most widely used alternative to Microsoft Office. We therefore consider it essential that any settlement on interoperability ensures that Free Software can use the information provided by Microsoft to compete on an equal footing.

Regarding interoperability, our core concerns are:

In both cases, we consider that an effective settlement is much preferable to one that is quickly achieved, but lacks the power to establish competition in the European market for desktop software.

We would like to thank you for considering these points, and hope that you find our analysis helpful. We of course remain available to provide further input.

Kind regards,

Karsten Gerloff

President, Free Software Foundation Europe